If he didn’t do that, he should have.

If you’ve ever spent any time with historians you know that they are the worst people to watch a movie with. Custer never said that, Roosevelt didn’t jump up from his wheelchair, there was no grass on that battlefield in 1917. A BETTER PEACE gathered three of our senior editors to lay waste to some of your favorite historical movies. Tom Bruscino, Jacqueline Whitt, and Ron Granieri sit down for a water cooler style discussion and tell us why we should be miserable watching movies like they are.

Thomas Bruscino is an Associate Professor at the U.S. Army War College and the Editor of the DUSTY SHELVES series. Jacqueline E. Whitt is an Associate Professor of Strategy at the U.S. Army War College and the Editor-in-Chief of WAR ROOM. Ron Granieri is an Associate Professor of History at the U.S. Army War College and the Editor of A BETTER PEACE. The views expressed in this presentation are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect those of the U.S. Army War College, U.S. Army, or Department of Defense.

Photo Description: Man working with a projector in a movie theater 1958

Photo Credit: This work is from the U.S. News & World Report collection at the Library of Congress.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Tags:

  • Show Comments

  • Bob

    If you really want to know what’s wrong with movies about Vietnam, check out Vietnam at the Movies, by Col. Michael Lee Lanning.

    Longley, Herring, Brigham, and Marilyn Young, et al…what nothing from anyone who actually went to Vietnam or, otherwise, has a different viewpoint? Very one-sided information for students of the War College (West Point, etc). No wonder the same mistakes are so often repeated, including thinking that what they view in the movies are real depictions of how things were.

  • Richard R. Allen

    There are a number of issues when considering what to say and how to make a war movie. First, a film maker would need an accurate historical record to begin with. In Misremembering the Holocaust: The Liberation of Buchenwald and the Limits of Memory, George R. Mastroianni identifies the problems historians face starting of page 122. It is not clear that all historians always use the correct methods to construct an accurate history. Memory requires three steps: encoding, storage, and retrieval. With the stress of battle and time memories can fail. An important element is “Social Correction” which S. L. A. Marshall used to reconstruct battles.
    Next film makers may fail to understand the psychology of performance. The books The Warrior Mindset: Mental Toughness Skills for a Nation’s Peacekeepers and On Combat provide resources on when and what level of enthusiasm and energy are needed for a specific combat tasks.
    In Is our Culture Rotting? How Do America’s Elites Stack Up? The American Interest Vol. XV No. 4 Seth D. Kaplan lays out a framework for deciding whether elites are, “Hubristic, aloof, and self-dealing – or humble, rooted, and self-sacrificing?” Using that framework, we would say this was true of the British Army before both WWI and WWII. As Captain B. H. Liddell Hart explained in his memoirs Vol. I and Vol. II, the elites of the British Army in the calvary regiments viewed the army more as a social club and not as force fight England’s enemies. Evelyn Waugh gave a fictional account of rotting culture in Men at Arms, Officers and Gentlemen, and Unconditional Surrender.
    In Nobody Knows Anything essay by William Voegeli Clairemont Review of Books, Vol. XX No. he points to a classic quote from William Goldman the screen writer. He said, “Nobody knows anything.” That is, “nobody, nobody – not now, not ever – knows that lead goddam thing about what is or isn’t going to work at the box office.” The problem is that people immerse themselves so closely in learning the mechanics of film making and only associating with others in the film industry that they lose touch with the ordinary man or woman and what they like. The obvious parallel is our armed forces spends all its time learning our strategy and tactics so that they lose touch of what it is to fight a war among peoples. They lose touch with what it is to fight a foreign culture.
    In The AEF Way of War Mark Ethan Grotelueschen describes how various divisions in the AEF adopted the tactics learned from the British and the French. Some division commanders were more successful in adapting to the new conditions. Unfortunately, General Pershing never understood the needed changes. Then the AEF lacked a process of systems analysis of battles such as S. L. A. Marshall was able to do. In How Behavior Spreads: The Science of Complex Contagions Damon Centola describes how the new tactics might have spread through out the AEF.
    Unfortunately for the film industry and our Armed Forces social contagions can adversely affect policies and staffing. In The Madness of Crowds: Gender, Race, and Identity by Douglas Murray describes how various trends in society can be carried to extremes that it is similar to social media lynch mob. Those trends will deform film making as the film industries seeks to portray war films in terms of the current social justice theories.

  • R J Del Vecchio

    Dr. Buscino, your article at Claremont is really excellent. This from a Vietnam vet, activist amateur historian of the “revisionist” school. In debates about the war, I use the Gordian Knot argument, which goes like this. Never mind anything about the war itself, let’s examine the results of the final victory by Hanoi, using of course more aid from Russia than the South got from us.
    When a war ends, what happens? In WW2 the showers of Zylon B stopped running, the horrific treatment of conquered people by the Japanese stopped, and people started rebuilding lives in comparative freedom all over. So we could all feel pretty good about the struggle and sacrifice and our morality in the fight.
    In South Viet Nam several tens of thousands were executed, 1.3MM went into “re-education” where many thousands more died, all civil liberties were gone, everyone who worked for RVN in any capacity became subject to official discrimination for themselves, their children, and grandchildren, and for the first ten years, there was near starvation. Things were so bad that 2 million people fled, at the risk of at least a 25% death rate, even including refugees from the North who went to China. Today the country is well known for its oppression of all dissent and enormous levels of corruption.
    So the question of who were really the good guys bringing “liberation and justice” to the South seems to have been answered very definitively.
    Were JFK’s words that we would fight any foe and bear any burden for the cause of liberty, not just for ourselves, but others as well, false and foolish? Many of us believed in that then, and that’s why we went, and that’s why we are sad about the eventual outcome, and remain strong in our view of those events.

  • Davidtow

    [b][size=4] 1. Kurgo Canine Backpack [/size][/b]

    [img]https://www.rover.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/41qaFMaHZYL.jpg[/img]

    This Kurgo puppy backpack is lightweight but still provides more compared to enough room to retail outlet the essentials.

    [b] What we just like about this: [/b]
    – Blue, crimson, or black/orange color choices
    – Leash add-on point in the trunk
    – Reflective lines intended for added visibility
    [b] Helpful Analyze: [/b] I have owned this product for well over the year, likely on two years now, in addition to it’ s superb and of very high quality. I are a great passionate hiker and love bringing my pet dog (GSP mix) on the particular trails with me. The lady loves to wear the woman group and gets super ecstatic at the eyesight of it. It contains some sort of few small objects yet is not substantial enough for a 17-ounce water bottle, so My partner and i had to get a new soft side waters package to put in it. She also carries a flip bowl, the tennis ball and 90 doggie bags and there’ s a good little bedroom left, consequently it does hold the fair amount of products. We certainly have given this piece A LOT of make use of, and it has kept up very well, not any holes, tears or even definitely any evident wear. ”

    [i] Available sizes: Baxter (30 to be able to 85 pounds) and Major Baxter (50 to one hundred ten pounds) [/i]
    Obtain At this moment on Chewy
    [b][size=4] installment payments on your KONG Trek Doggie Load up [/size][/b]

    [img]https://www.rover.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/41Wc2yknULL.jpg[/img]

    This KONG cure puppy pack is some sort of snap to put on and sets for a perfect fit.

    [b] Everything we want about it: [/b]
    – Large area pocket has some sort of integrated key holder
    – Stylish blue color along with reflective silver trim
    – Interior straps to keep your water bottle in spot
    [b] Helpful Review: [/b] “ This backpack can be great! Purchased to offer my 75-pound American Bulldog a good ‘ job’ in addition to this individual seemed to be immediately far better carried on on our walks. My partner and i ordered this L/XL credited to his huge upper body and large head although had to adjust typically the straps all the way to their most compact. My partner and i almost certainly could experience got away with a small size. The pack is not hard to fit and change, the bags are roomier when compared with We expected, and seems very tough. I’ empieza solely recently been putting little ankle joint weights on every side but I’ n looking forward to improving the weight as the doggy gets more used to holding it. ”

    [i] Obtainable sizes: Moderate and Giant [/i]

    [b][size=4] several. Ruffwear Full-Day Walking Pack For Dogs, Extra-Small [/size][/b]

    [img]https://www.rover.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/51PbHEfxdaL.jpg[/img]

    This specific Ruffwear hiking bunch is well-worth the investment: The idea boasts lightweight substance inside an ultra-visible orange shade with large pockets and comfy padding.

    [b] What we like about the idea: [/b]
    – Nonslip straps make sure the pack goes toward location
    – Shock absorbing handle allows you to assistance find their way your dog
    – Operate the V-ring in the top to affix into a leash

    [b] Helpful Analysis: [/b] “ Amazing family dog backpack! I explored with regard to many months before last but not least buying this one since the price was obviously a whole lot to justify to me. My partner and i am glad My partner and i acquired this pack. Most of us experimented with on cheaper variants at the local pet shops but they moved all around excessive and would not fit in fact. The luggage fit A LOT associated with goods in them! Right now there is almost also very much room but if you’ re hiking as well as using day trips this will be a good issue. Total I would absolutely advise taking the plunge and even buying this puppy book bag. ”

    [i] One size merely [/i]

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *